A zero day response plan is ten clauses long, and its drill proves that the authority table works
The plan is the emergency branch of the vulnerability plan, and it settles who may act
NIST SP 800-40 Rev. 4, section 3.3, tells organizations to define risk response scenarios in advance: routine patching, emergency patching, emergency mitigation and unpatchable assets. Section 3.5.3 gives the reason: "Without the processes, procedures, and tools in place to implement mitigations, too much time may be lost, and vulnerable assets may be compromised." Section 3.5.2 allows a canary period of "a few minutes to a few hours" even in an emergency.
NIST SP 800-61 Rev. 3 separates incident response plans from vulnerability management plans and business continuity plans. The zero day plan belongs to the vulnerability side and hands over to the incident response plan once compromise is suspected, so it names that hand-over. SP 800-61r3 also suggests: "Consider designating an incident lead for each incident."
The deadlines in the plan come from how fast attacks start. In the Disclosure Clock, 33 bugs have a dated first exploitation: 16 within one day of disclosure, 24 within seven days, and a median gap of 2 days. By the end of day 3, 19 of the 33 had been exploited, so a plan that takes three days to find an approver acts after more than half of them have been under attack. The role playbooks hold the step-by-step work; the plan holds the authority, the triggers and the deadlines.
Ten clauses make the plan complete
Each row is a clause. Fill the second column with your own facts and name the owner in the third. The fifth column is the record the clause leaves, which a reviewer can ask for.
Scroll the table sideways for more columns
| Clause | What to write | Owner | How it typically fails | Record it produces |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Scope | What the plan covers: vulnerabilities with evidence of exploitation, and critical flaws in products reachable from outside. The products and asset classes in scope, what is out of scope and who covers it (vendor-hosted services, for example). Review date | Security lead | Vendor-hosted and supplier-run copies are left out, so the first one found mid-event has no owner. | Signed scope list with its review date |
| 2. Triggers | The levels in the trigger table below, with who declares each | Security lead | Triggers read only CVSS, so a low-rated bug in the catalog starts nothing. | Trigger table with a version number; each declaration logs the trigger and its source |
| 3. Roles and deputies | Event lead, platform lead, application owners, change approver, communications lead, executive approver and scribe. Each has a named deputy and a phone number that works at night | Security lead | A deputy's phone number is out of date, or the deputy has never run an event. | Roster with names, deputies and numbers, and the date of the last call test |
| 4. Standing pre-approvals | Mitigations the event lead may apply without the change board, each with its known cost and the people told: restrict a management interface to a jump host, disable a named feature, turn on a WAF rule in block mode, take a service off the internet | Change approver | A pre-approval nobody has costed is vetoed by the service owner on the night. | Pre-approval list with cost, people told and review date |
| 5. Inputs | Advisory feeds for every vendor in the inventory, the CISA catalog, and the vendor portal accounts needed to read advisories behind a login, with a named holder and deputy. The inventory fields the first hour needs: product, version, role, exposure, owner, maintenance group | Platform lead | The one holder of a vendor portal login is away, and the advisory sits unread behind it. | Feed and portal-holder list; inventory export with its date |
| 6. Deadlines | Event declared within 1 hour of a trigger. Count of exposed assets within 2 hours. A first control on every internet-facing exposed asset within 4 hours. Patch ring 1 within 24 hours. Fix verified or risk accepted in writing within 72 hours. Replace these with figures you can meet | Event lead | The deadlines were copied from a template and never met, so the team ignores them. | Timestamps in the decision log for declaration, count, first control, each patch ring and verification |
| 7. Communications | Update interval (4 hours while exploitation is active), the channel, who may speak to customers, regulators and the board, and each notification duty with its trigger and deadline. Leave a duty blank rather than guess | Communications lead | Nobody owns the decision that the organization is aware of an incident, so a notification clock starts unnoticed. | Update log with time, audience and approver; register of notification duties |
| 8. Exceptions | A named person and a written answer for each: advisory behind a login, product owned by another team or a supplier, version with no fix, restart refused in business hours, approver away at a weekend, vendor-hosted copy | Security lead | The exception names a team, not a person, and the question lands in a queue. | Exception register: person, written answer, date |
| 9. Records | One decision log. Each entry holds time in UTC, decision, owner, reason and expiry. The event closes when every in-scope asset has a verified fixed build or a signed acceptance with an expiry | Scribe | Decisions stay in chat and the log is rebuilt from memory after the event. | The decision log, and its closure entry |
| 10. Test and review | The drill below twice a year, a review within 72 hours of every real event, and a version history showing what each review changed | Security lead | The drill is skipped after a reorganization and the roles list names people who have left. | Drill report with times and the plan lines changed; version history |
Two levels and a compromise flag decide when the plan starts
Name the trigger before the day it is needed, so that nobody debates it during the first hour.
When sources disagree, the higher level applies. An empty catalog is not a reason to wait. Apache Tomcat CVE-2026-34486 was disclosed on 9 Apr 2026, SOCRadar dates attacks against it from 24 Apr, and CISA listed it on 4 Aug, 102 days after the first attack.
Scroll the table sideways for more columns
| Level | Trigger (any one) | Declared by | Within | What changes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Watch | A critical rating (CVSS 9.0 or higher) on a product in the inventory that is reachable from outside, with no statement of exploitation | Analyst on duty | The same business day | Inventory count and mitigation options prepared. No out-of-band changes yet |
| Event | The vendor says exploitation is under way; the CVE is in the CISA catalog; a named security firm reports attacks on a product in the inventory | Event lead or deputy | 1 hour from first sight | Pre-approvals are active, the update clock starts, the decision log opens |
| Compromise | Evidence of exploitation on one of your own assets | Event lead | At once | Hand over to the incident response plan. Preserve evidence before patching |
The authority table says who decides what, and for how long
The limits are defaults to replace with your own. Their purpose is that every decision on the first night has an owner with a deputy and a ceiling.
Scroll the table sideways for more columns
| Decision | Decides | If unavailable | Limit (default) | Logged as |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Declare a Watch or an Event | Event lead | Named SOC lead | None | Trigger, source, time |
| Apply a pre-approved mitigation | Event lead | Platform lead | Pre-approval list only; reviewed at each update | Mitigation, cost, owner, expiry |
| Approve an out-of-band change | Change approver | Deputy approver, then the executive on call | 60 minutes to answer | Request time, answer time, approver |
| Take a service offline | Event lead, service owner informed | Executive | 24 hours without owner consent | Service, reason, restore condition |
| Accept a risk | Executive | Deputy executive | 30 days; renewal needs a new signature | Asset group, reason, expiry |
| Speak to customers or regulators | Communications lead with legal | Executive | Only facts the event lead has confirmed | Statement and approver |
| Close the event | Event lead | Security lead | Verified build or signed acceptance for every asset | Closure criteria met |
When the usual answer is wrong
A Watch trigger set at CVSS 9.0 never opens for a bug rated low that is already exploited. Broadcom rates ESX CVE-2026-41709 at CVSS 2.7, and CISA added it to the catalog on 28 Oct 2026. Microsoft's Windows CVE-2026-68820 is rated 7.0 and was marked exploited on the day its fix shipped, 11 Aug 2026. The Event trigger must therefore key on exploitation evidence and catalog listing for products in the inventory, whatever the rating.
A one-hour declaration clock assumes the attack starts at disclosure. For BeyondTrust CVE-2026-102764 it started on 29 Aug 2026, 47 days before the 15 Oct advisory, so an Event declared on 15 Oct opens with the Compromise flag already in question and a search window of 47 days.
The drill: a Cisco ISE tabletop with timed injects
Run it twice a year for one hour with the people named in the authority table, using a real advisory. This one is Cisco's cisco-sa-ISE-ABP-VNSW7Tn5, first published 16 Sep 2026 at 16:00 GMT. It is CVE-2026-76460, an authentication bypass in an ISE API, base rating 10.0, and it affects ISE and ISE-PIC regardless of configuration. Cisco lists no workaround, recommends infrastructure access control lists, and names these fixed patches: ISE 3.1 Patch 12, 3.2 Patch 11, 3.3 Patch 12, 3.4 Patch 7 and 3.5 Patch 4. ISE 3.0 is past software maintenance and has no fix.
Teams answer from their real inventory. A team that runs no ISE uses an invented card of its own, for example 2 nodes on 3.2 Patch 9, 3 on 3.4 Patch 6 and 1 on 3.0. The scribe records the clock time of every answer.
Afterward, compare five times with clause 6: declaration, first inventory answer, first control, approver reached and statement approved. Each miss becomes a changed line in the plan with an owner and a date.
Scroll the table sideways for more columns
| Drill clock | Inject | Expected answer | Pass condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| T+0:00 | The advisory arrives. CISA lists the CVE the same day | Event declared: the vendor states exploitation and the catalog lists it | Declared and logged within 1 hour, trigger named |
| T+0:30 | "Which nodes do we run, and which patch level?" | Per node: 3.2 needs Patch 11, 3.4 needs Patch 7, 3.0 has no fix and needs a move to a supported release | Count from the real inventory within 2 hours |
| T+1:00 | The network owner objects to access control lists on the ISE nodes | Pre-approved mitigation: allow only required management and control plane traffic. Cost: any admin station or integration not on the list loses access, so list the callers first | Mitigation applied within 4 hours, with its cost and an expiry in the log |
| T+2:00 | The change approver does not answer the phone | Deputy approver, then the executive on call | Someone with authority is reached within 60 minutes |
| T+3:00 | An application owner refuses a restart in business hours | Ring schedule or a signed acceptance with an expiry date | Decision logged with owner and expiry |
| T+4:00 | On one node, the command show logging application ise-kong/access.log | include dummyuser returns an entry for a suspicious username | Move to the Compromise flag, hand over to the incident response plan, check every node, cross-check firewall logs outside the device because Cisco says evidence may be removed, and re-image as Cisco recommends | Flag changed and evidence preserved before any re-image |
| T+5:00 | A customer asks whether you are affected | Communications lead with legal, using confirmed facts only | Statement approved by the named person |
An example drill result, constructed
The result below is invented to show the form. It uses the invented card above (2 nodes on 3.2 Patch 9, 3 on 3.4 Patch 6 and 1 on 3.0) and is not a record of a real team.
Scroll the table sideways for more columns
| Time compared | Clause 6 target | Constructed result | Plan line changed | Owner and date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Declaration | 1 hour | 1 h 20 min: the analyst waited for the event lead, who was in a meeting | Clause 2: the deputy event lead may declare an Event on the catalog trigger alone | Security lead, 14 days |
| First inventory answer | 2 hours | 3 h 10 min: patch level is not an inventory field, so each node was logged into by hand | Clause 5: add patch level to the inventory fields the first hour needs | Platform lead, 30 days |
| First control | 4 hours | 3 h 40 min: met; the access-list pre-approval was used | None | None |
| Approver reached | 60 minutes | 1 h 50 min: the deputy approver's number was out of date | Clause 3: the roster is call-tested each quarter | Security lead, 14 days |
| Statement approved | Named person approves | 5 h 25 min: met, with the confirmed facts only | None | None |
Related pages
Sources
- NIST SP 800-40 Rev. 4, Guide to Enterprise Patch Management Planning, read 19 Nov 2026
- NIST SP 800-61 Rev. 3, Incident Response Recommendations and Considerations, read 19 Nov 2026
- Cisco advisory cisco-sa-ISE-ABP-VNSW7Tn5, read 19 Nov 2026
- CISA Known Exploited Vulnerabilities catalog, read 19 Nov 2026
- SOCRadar: SNOWLIGHT campaign, Tomcat exploitation dates, read 19 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 19 Nov 2026.